Is China Set To Outpace the U.S. In Mars Sample Returns?

China has accelerated its timeline for returning Mars samples to Earth, aiming to complete the mission ahead of the United States. NASA’s Mars sample return initiative, a collaborative effort with the European Space Agency (ESA), faces ongoing scrutiny. A newly formed strategy review team is tasked with advising NASA’s leadership, with recommendations expected by the end of the year or early next.

China’s Revised Timeline

At a recent conference hosted by China’s Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Liu Jizhong, chief designer of the Mars sample-return project, announced that the Tianwen-3 mission is now set for launch around 2028—two years earlier than originally planned. “It will take two launches to carry out the Mars sample-return mission due to the limited carrying capacities of our current rockets. Two Long March-5 carrier rockets will be used for the mission,” Liu told the state-run Xinhua news agency.

China’s approach draws on its successful lunar sample-return missions, such as Chang’e 5 and Chang’e 6. The planned Tianwen-3 mission will involve collecting samples from the Martian surface and returning them to Earth, utilizing technology similar to that used in the lunar missions.

The Scientific Imperative

The primary objective of Tianwen-3 is to search for signs of life on Mars. Chinese space experts have emphasized that the mission will include international collaboration, sharing of samples and data, and joint planning for future missions. “Engineering constraints do not respect national boundaries,” said James Head, a planetary scientist at Brown University, suggesting that Utopia Planitia might be a strong candidate for the sample collection site, given China’s prior successful exploration there.

A Political Dimension

Scott Hubbard, a former NASA Mars program director, highlighted the political implications of China’s endeavors. “If, as has been reported, China successfully executes even a ‘grab sample’ at Mars and returns it safely to Earth before the U.S., that would constitute a ‘Sputnik Moment,’” he noted. Hubbard acknowledged that while a grab sample may not offer the scientific depth of NASA’s carefully selected cores, the symbolic victory of a “China beats U.S.” headline could carry significant weight.

Harry McSween from the University of Tennessee echoed concerns about U.S. leadership in Mars exploration. “After doing so much planning and effort in Mars sample return, it would be distressing if the U.S. and our European partners don’t bring back the first samples,” he stated, emphasizing the transformative potential of Martian samples.

Looking Ahead

The ongoing competition raises questions about future exploration. Chris McKay from NASA’s Ames Research Center noted that a simpler, more direct approach might have yielded Mars samples by now, similar to China’s lunar missions. “Is it too late to go back to a simple Step 1?” he asked, reflecting on NASA’s more complex plans that have faced delays.

As the stakes rise, planetary scientist Pascal Lee articulated a mixed response to China’s progress. “As a scientist, my thoughts are ‘Yay…that’s great! More samples from Mars, and sooner the better!’ But from a space strategy standpoint, this would be yet another wakeup call,” he remarked. The potential for China to lead in returning samples from Mars could have significant implications for future human exploration of the planet.

(Includes inputs from online sources.)

ALSO READ: Underground Schools In Ukraine: A Response To Bombs And Radiation Risks