The Biden administration’s efforts to cancel student loans for millions of Americans could face a significant setback as Donald Trump returns to the White House. Trump’s position on student loan forgiveness has been clear, labeling the initiative as “vile” and questioning its legality.
Legal Roadblocks to Debt Cancellation
As Trump assumes office again in January, experts predict that his administration will halt the defense of the Biden administration’s student loan forgiveness programs in court. Trump’s Republican allies have already filed multiple lawsuits challenging these plans. According to higher education expert Mark Kantrowitz, Trump could instruct his administration to withdraw its defense of ongoing legal cases, potentially halting the progress of the forgiveness efforts.
Trump’s Criticism of Biden’s Student Loan Forgiveness Plans
At a campaign rally in June 2023, Trump expressed his approval of the Supreme Court’s decision to block President Biden’s first attempt at broad student loan cancellation. Trump stated that Biden’s repeated efforts to push forward with loan forgiveness would face more setbacks, as the proposals were “going to get rebuked again.”
Impact on Borrowers and Legal Challenges
With Trump returning to the presidency, millions of borrowers who had been promised relief may find themselves back in repayment mode. The Biden administration’s most recent efforts, which followed a Supreme Court defeat, could also falter in the absence of strong legal defense. Recent legal actions, such as a ruling from St. Louis-based U.S. District Judge Matthew Schelp, have already blocked parts of Biden’s revised forgiveness plan, which aimed to assist 3 in 4 federal student loan holders.
Political and Legal Tensions Ahead Over Student Loan Relief
Experts anticipate a prolonged legal battle over student loan relief, with Republicans likely seeking to delay proceedings while the Biden administration attempts to expedite them. Kantrowitz notes that the outcome will largely depend on the actions of both political parties as the election results unfold.
Biden’s Record on Student Loan Relief
Despite challenges, President Biden has successfully cancelled more student loan debt than any of his predecessors. Over his tenure, more than $175 billion in debt relief has been granted to approximately 5 million borrowers. This has been largely achieved through improvements to existing relief programs, such as the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program, which Biden expanded to assist over 1 million people.
Trump’s Stance on Education Policy and Debt Relief
Trump’s previous presidency saw proposals to eliminate the PSLF program and reduce the affordability of student loan repayment options. These proposals could gain traction again if Republicans maintain control of Congress. Critics argue that these changes would harm working families, as many depend on the student loan relief programs to ease financial burdens.
Public Opinion and Political Divide
The public remains divided on student loan forgiveness. A national poll revealed that only 15% of Republicans view loan forgiveness as important, compared to 58% of Democrats. Supporters of loan forgiveness argue that rising tuition costs have forced many families into debt to secure a college education, a necessity for achieving middle-class status. Meanwhile, student debt disproportionately affects women and people of color.
Concerns About For-Profit Schools and Trump’s Legacy
Another point of contention is Trump’s relationship with the for-profit education sector. During his presidency, Trump halted regulations intended to forgive loans for students defrauded by for-profit institutions. His own involvement with Trump University, which was criticized for misleading students, adds to concerns among consumer advocates that a return to office could favor such institutions.
Criticism from Key Political Figures
Critics, including Senator JD Vance of Ohio, argue that student debt forgiveness benefits the wealthy and well-educated, labeling it a windfall for corrupt university administrators. However, advocates for forgiveness, like Jane Fox from the Legal Aid Society, argue that debt relief primarily benefits working-class individuals and that such claims about helping the rich are misleading, especially when those with significant wealth rarely need such assistance.
Read More: US Election Explained: Why Young Men Voted For Donald Trump?
