As the US heads toward Election Day on November 5, Pennsylvania’s mail-in ballot rules have raised concerns about a potential crisis in provisional voting. Under recent legal clarifications, mail ballots could be rejected if voters fail to properly date the affidavits that accompany them. With around 390,000 outstanding mail ballots and a tight deadline for their receipt—by 8 p.m. on Election Day—many voters in Pennsylvania could face the prospect of voting in person to ensure their ballots are counted. For voters encountering issues with their mail ballots, provisional ballots remain an option on Election Day, though these ballots will only be counted after verifying the status of mail-in ballots.
A Crucial Swing State Faces Provisional Ballot Surge
Pennsylvania, long known as a critical swing state, is poised to see a surge in provisional ballots during this election, potentially complicating the tallying process. According to public data from the Pennsylvania Secretary of State, around 2.2 million Pennsylvanians had applied for mail ballots as of the latest count. Of those, approximately 82% have already returned their ballots, leaving around 390,000 mail ballots still unaccounted for with just days to go before the election. This sets the stage for a significant number of voters to potentially cast provisional ballots, especially given the tight race between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump.
While provisional ballots do not directly impact the outcome unless there are disputes, they can play a crucial role in determining the final result in a close election. This could be especially important in a battleground state like Pennsylvania, where both candidates are neck and neck, and every vote counts.
Provisional Ballots Likely to Favor Democrats in Pennsylvania
Historically, provisional ballots tend to lean in favor of Democratic candidates. If trends from the 2022 election hold, around 150,000 more mail ballots are expected to be counted after Election Day, either through the mail or via drop boxes. This could mean a substantial number of votes, many of which may still be processed through provisional ballots. In 2022, one-third of voters who requested mail ballots but did not return them cast their votes in person instead. If this trend continues, approximately 90,000 voters might choose to cast ballots in person, with around 35,000 expected to rely on provisional ballots.
The implications of this are significant, particularly in a tightly contested election. If these provisional ballots are accepted, they could play a crucial role in tipping the scales in favor of the Democrats, especially if many of the outstanding mail ballots come from more liberal-leaning districts.
Challenges for Voters with Mail Ballots and the Provisional Voting Option
For voters facing issues with their mail ballots, provisional voting provides a backup option. Voters who present their mail ballots at polling stations can exchange them for regular ballots. However, if they do not have their mail ballots with them, they will have to vote using a provisional ballot. These ballots will only be counted after election officials confirm that the voter’s original mail ballot was not processed. This process can cause delays in determining the final outcome, particularly in Pennsylvania, where the volume of mail ballots and provisional ballots could be substantial.
In a race as tight as the one between Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, every vote matters. As such, provisional ballots could be a deciding factor in who ultimately wins Pennsylvania, one of the most hotly contested states in the 2024 election.
Legal Rulings and Voting Rights: A Victory for Voters
Adding to the uncertainty surrounding provisional ballots, the U.S. Supreme Court recently dismissed an emergency appeal from Republican officials that could have led to thousands of provisional ballots being excluded in Pennsylvania. The Court upheld a decision by Pennsylvania’s highest court that requires election officials to tally ballots cast by voters whose mail-in ballots were rejected due to minor errors, such as missing dates. This ruling has been seen as a victory for voting rights advocates who argue that even small mistakes, such as a missing date on the envelope, should not disqualify a voter from having their voice heard.
The ruling means that voters whose mail ballots were rejected for technical reasons will still be able to cast provisional ballots on Election Day, which will be counted after verifying that their mail ballots were not processed. This decision aligns with the broader push to ensure that voters are not disenfranchised due to minor errors, which could disproportionately affect certain groups of voters.
However, despite this win for voting rights, Republicans have claimed a partial victory in a separate legal matter: the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision to prohibit the counting of mail ballots that do not have a clear handwritten date on the envelope. This ruling will apply to the upcoming presidential election and could impact the final count of mail-in ballots, further complicating the process in an already high-stakes election.
The Key Role of Provisional Ballots in a Tight Election
With the potential for a surge in provisional ballots, Pennsylvania’s election could see delayed results, depending on the number of provisional ballots cast and the time required to verify them. Election officials will be tasked with ensuring that these ballots are properly processed and counted, which could take several days after Election Day. This could delay the final certification of the vote, especially if the margin of victory is narrow.
In such a high-profile election, where Pennsylvania is one of the most important battleground states, provisional ballots could have a major impact on the outcome. As voters encounter issues with their mail-in ballots, the use of provisional ballots could grow, influencing the final result in ways that may not be immediately clear on Election Night.
In a race as tight as the one between Harris and Trump, any vote cast via provisional ballot could be crucial. As the state’s legal and procedural rules evolve in real time, it will be important to track the provisional ballots and how they are counted in the days following the election. With the outcome in Pennsylvania likely to play a key role in the overall election, the handling of provisional ballots may ultimately determine the winner of the state—and perhaps the nation.
Read More : Who Are Trump’s ‘Proud Boys’? Far-Right Groups Mobilize As MAGA Leader Amplifies Election Fraud Claims